The Harborplace redevelopment plan includes a nine-story building with a series of roof terraces that both curve and step up at an angle, depicted in this rendering. Credit: MCB Real Estate.
The Harborplace redevelopment plan includes a nine-story building with a series of roof terraces that both curve and step up at an angle, depicted in this rendering. Credit: MCB Real Estate.

Maryor Brandon Scott this week unveiled the terms of the city’s Harborplace Redevelopment Agreement with MCB Real Estate.

The agreement outlines the terms under which the city will lease public land to MCB, which wants to demolish the current Harborplace pavilions at Pratt and Light streets and replace them with a $900 million-plus mixed-use development containing two apartment towers, offices, a hotel, shops, restaurants and open space.

MCB owns the two pavilions and the city owns the land beneath them. MCB needs a long-term lease agreement to be approved by the city before it can move ahead with its project, first unveiled in October 2023. Construction is expected to take five years or more.

The agreement is the result of months of planning and negotiations by the Mayor’s Office, the Baltimore Development Corporation and MCB. It will be presented to Baltimore’s Board of Estimates for approval at a meeting on Dec. 2.

According to the Mayor’s Office, the agreement between the City and MCB includes four key components that together are intended to bring “significant financial, economic and community benefits to the entire City in both the short and long term.”

The four components are:

“My main priority from day one of these negotiations has been getting a good deal for our residents,” Scott said in a statement. “Over my lifetime, I’ve seen countless deals that advantaged private developers at Baltimore’s expense, and I was committed to doing things differently in this negotiation. I’m confident that this agreement is one that Baltimoreans can be proud of, and will help us build an Inner Harbor that is truly for all of us.”

Under this agreement, the Mayor’s Office said, the City will receive more than three times the amount of tax revenue generated by the existing pavilions at their current rate of depreciation.

“These tax dollars will go directly into the City’s General Fund, to be spent across Baltimore on critical investments like libraries, housing, recreation centers, parks, and schools,” according to the Mayor’s announcement. “In addition to direct tax revenue, which establishes a minimum paid by the developer over the course of the PILOT agreement, the project is projected to generate an estimated $2 billion in economic activity during construction alone.”

As part of the comprehensive Community Benefits Agreement package negotiated for the redevelopment, MCB has agreed to place $10 million in a community fund to benefit Downtown. This additional funding will be overseen by an advisory board and will support initiatives such as summer youth engagement, Youthworks, free outdoor events and graffiti removal. 

Public maintenance workers will be represented by a Collective Bargaining Agreement, to include AFSCME members, ensuring that workers covering the development area are union employees. At the Mayor’s direction, MCB is in negotiations with UNITE HERE and the building trades to establish agreements for their respective workforces to take part in the project.

Under the negotiated agreement, MCB cannot begin construction without demonstrating to the City’s satisfaction that it has secured financing to complete each phase of the project. It is unclear from the information released, some observers say, whether demolition of the existing Harborplace pavilions is considered the start. Over the course of the redevelopment, MCB and BDC agree provide regular public updates on progress, including the release of annual audits of financial statements.

‘We still have much work to do’

“When we first bid on this project to bring it out of receivership, our main goal at MCB was to deliver a project that enhanced our world-class waterfront,” said P. David Bramble, Managing Partner, MCB Real Estate, in a statement.

“I am thankful to Mayor Scott for believing not just in the MCB team but also in a better future for the Inner Harbor,” Bramble said. “While the announcement today is a critical step forward, we still have much work to do. We are showing the world that Baltimore is ready for the kinds of big investment that we deserve — and we are excited to show what that future can look like.”

“Harborplace is a major opportunity for Baltimore, and the PILOT is what makes redevelopment possible,” said Otis Rolley III, President & CEO of BDC, in the city’s announcement.“BDC put the right tool to work to move the project forward and position Harborplace for the investment it deserves. That is meaningful progress for downtown and the city.”

Economic activity

The Mayor’s Office said an estimated $2 billion in economic activity from construction includes: $26.4 million in direct revenue to the City of Baltimore and more than 8,500 construction jobs paying an estimated $648.6 million in labor income. In addition, 35 percent of construction hours are expected to be worked by Baltimore residents, and 40 percent of construction contracts will be filled by Disadvantage Business Enterprises and Woman-owned Business Enterprises, under the agreement.

Other economic benefits cited by the Mayor’s Office include:  

  • 55 percent of new hires for permanent jobs must be Baltimore residents. 
  • Public maintenance workers will be represented by a Collective Bargaining Agreement, and will include AFSCME members.
  • If the Harborplace project outperforms profit expectations by 20%, the deal calls for Baltimore to receive 20 percent those profits.
  • MCB will invest $10 million in a community fund, delivering direct support for priorities under the Downtown RISE strategy.
  • MCB will offer a $5 million equity fund, an opportunity for Baltimore residents to invest directly in the Harborplace project and share in the profits. 

Affordable housing

The Mayor’s Office said the agreement states that 10 percent of residential units will be set aside for affordable housing, which is calculated at up to 60 percent of the median income in the area. Four and a half acres of new parks and public spaces will be created, for a total of 18.7 acres, because the planned buildings will occupy less space at ground level than the current pavilions do.

More than 500 new trees are to be planted along the public promenade, and wetlands will intercept and remove nutrients from the Harbor. The agreement also calls for replacement of the Inner Harbor seawall from the Maryland Science Center around to the National Aquarium and for the seawall and Inner Harbor promenade to be raised to respond to rising sea levels and improve sustainability. A two-tier promenade has been designed to respond to flooding.

Scott’s announcement about the Harborplace Redevelopment agreement came on the same day that Baltimore’s Planning Commission approved City Council legislation that would close the five-lane Light Street-to-Calvert Street traffic spur near Harborplace.

MCB is seeking to make the roadbed of the eliminated traffic spur part of the footprint of its development. The bill will next be the subject of a public hearing by the city council’s Land Use and Transportation Committee.

Because Scott controls three of the five votes on the Board of Estimates, the Harborplace Redevelopment Agreement is expected win approval.

Opposition continues

A group of seven Baltimore residents and business owners sued the city and MCB Real Estate in September to block the demolition of Harborplace’s existing pavilions and halt redevelopment, and they filed a request for a preliminary injunction in mid-November.

The complaint filed in Baltimore City Circuit Court argues that city officials violated the Baltimore City Charter, zoning rules, urban renewal requirements, and Maryland’s constitutional ban on certain “special laws” when approving three March 2024 bills that allowed multifamily housing, removed a 100-foot height limit, and altered public parkland protections at the Inner Harbor.

After Scott announced the terms of the city’s agreement with MCB, a citizens’ group that has questioned MCB’s project, the Inner Harbor Coalition, released a three-paragraph response. Its title is: “Harborplace for All — A Statement from the Inner Harbor Coalition on the Proposed Harborplace Redevelopment Agreement.”

Here is the statement:

We live in an era of alternative facts when the words and actions of elected leaders are verifiably untrue. Yesterday’s unsurprising announcement from City Hall and BDC on the proposed Harborplace redevelopment agreement unfortunately bear this out.

We have been told that Baltimoreans in taxpayer-funded MCB-led listening sessions want luxury apartments and hotel rooms we can’t afford in public parkland at the harbor’s edge. Harbor-adjacent communities have been told closing existing roadways would improve their quality of life and property values. Repeated promises there would be no demolition of the internationally acclaimed historic pavilions and amphitheater prior to full plan approval and project funding secured are broken as have repeated pledges MCB would not be seeking financial assistance from taxpayers. We are told that making it impossible for tall ships and gray hulls to berth along the west wall is good for our community pride, identity and economy. That waiting 13 more years for a speculative build out after decades of decline is better than an immediate reset of a proven winning formula. These are just a few of the egregious falsehoods we are to believe.

The Inner Harbor Coalition and its growing number of allies remain committed to using law, regulation and the facts to keep Harborplace and the Inner Harbor verifiably a place for all.

More information from the city and MCB about the agreement and the development plan is available at baltimorecity.gov/harborplace and on MCB’s website, www.ourharborplace.com.

Ed Gunts is a local freelance writer and the former architecture critic for The Baltimore Sun.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *