An aerial view of Harborplace. Photo credit: Ed Gunts.
An aerial view of Harborplace. Photo credit: Ed Gunts.

A proposal by the Scott administration to close part of Light Street near Pratt Street moved closer to implementation on Thursday after Baltimore’s Planning Commission approved a City Council bill needed to make it possible.

The commission voted 6-0 on Thursday to approve Council Bill 06-0256, which would authorize the city to condemn and close portions of Calvert, Light and Pratt streets near the two Harborplace pavilions. Commission chair Jon Laria, whose law firm has represented Harborplace’s owner in the past, recused himself from voting and left the meeting room while the agenda item was discussed.

The portion of Light Street that would be closed is the five-lane Light Street-to-Calvert Street “spur” that northbound drivers use to get to Calvert Street or Pratt Street from Light Street.

The curving road separates the Harborplace pavilions and the Inner Harbor amphitheater from McKeldin Square, the one-acre open space created after Baltimore’s McKeldin Fountain was demolished 10 years ago. The spur was created to streamline the flow of traffic around Pratt and Light streets and save drivers time, though it means pedestrians must cross five lanes of traffic.

MCB Real Estate, the owner of the Harborplace pavilions, is seeking control of the roadbed to make it part of the footprint for a $900 million-plus mixed-use development proposed for where the pavilions now stand. The city would retain ownership of the land and lease it to MCB. The proposed development would include two residential towers containing 900 apartments, offices, shops, restaurants and open space.

During the commission meeting on Thursday, Planning Department director Renata Southard told panel members that the plan to eliminate the Light Street spur has been approved by the commission several times before, most recently last February and as far back as 2013.

Southard said the commission has previously supported the idea of closing five lanes of Light Street traffic largely because that would make the area safer for pedestrians. She said it would be inconsistent for the commission to vote against a plan that it has previously endorsed. “As a legal matter, the Planning Commission can’t change its mind” when facts haven’t changed, she said.

Of 10 people who testified about the bill both online and in person, eight were against the proposal. According to Downtown planner Caitlin Audette, the commission also received three letters or email messages indicating support for the street closing legislation, three letters expressing concern about it and 24 letters in opposition.

Opponents of the legislation warned that eliminating the spur would slow travel times downtown, create traffic jams and lead to increased traffic in residential areas such as Otterbein.

The strongest proponent of the bill was South Baltimore resident and city housing department chief operating officer Cassie Clemente, who said she supports the idea of creating more housing downtown.

“Every problem gets better when we have more neighbors,” she told the commission. “We believe the city should be for people, not cars.”

The bill now goes to the City Council’s Land Use and Transportation Committee for a hearing. No hearing date has been set.

Several of the opponents urged the Planning Commission to recommend that the city’s transportation department close Light Street on a trial basis before making it permanent.

“Try it out and see what happens,” said former City Council member Tony Ambridge.

“Do a test run, see how it works for a couple of days,’ agreed Barbara Hampton, suggesting Tuesday through Thursday to start.

“I encourage you to run a test when there is a Ravens game, when there is an Orioles game, when the CFG Arena has a big act,” said Inner Harbor resident Donna Beth Joy Shapiro, who spoke against the street closure plan. “This is magical thinking, all of this, to me.”

Ed Gunts is a local freelance writer and the former architecture critic for The Baltimore Sun.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *